County property tax calculator
Property Tax Calculator for Cattaraugus County
Cattaraugus County carries one of the heaviest property tax loads in the country. At 2.693%, the effective rate runs well above the 1.07% US average — a gap that shows up every month in escrow. On the county's median home value of $109,400, the annual tax bill comes to $2,946, or roughly $246 per month paid through the mortgage servicer. Buyers relocating from lower-tax states often notice the difference in their first escrow analysis. Local services funded by property tax — schools, roads, emergency response — tend to reflect the higher rate, but so does the buyer's monthly carrying cost. Anyone considering a purchase here should factor the tax load into affordability math before the offer. Cattaraugus County is one of the more affordable markets in New York. A median home value of $109,400 places entry-level pricing within reach for first-time buyers and investors alike. With FHA loans at 3.5% down or VA loans at 0%, the barrier to entry is often the lowest in the region. Lower valuations also mean lower absolute tax bills and insurance premiums. The trade-off may be distance from major employment centers or access to specific school districts. Buyers exploring this tier should compare commute cost and time against the lower purchase price. Rental demand in entry-priced markets is often steady, which supports the investor case. With entry-level pricing and access to first-time buyer programs, this market often allows buyers to enter with a smaller cash reserve than premium or expensive tiers would require.
Property Tax Details
National average is 1.07%
Used to project future tax burden
Annual Property Tax
$0
Insights
Property Tax Landscape in Cattaraugus County
Cattaraugus County's 2.693% effective rate runs well above New York's statewide average of 1.55%. That 1.143 percentage-point gap equals roughly $1,250 per year on a median-valued home — a meaningful line item for buyers comparing jurisdictions. The county's higher rate typically funds a combination of local school, municipal, and county services that may not be fully covered by state transfers. Buyers relocating from other parts of New York or from lower-tax states should include this in their affordability model. The differential compounds over the life of the loan, so long-term owners in this county pay materially more tax than their counterparts elsewhere in the state. Within New York, Cattaraugus County ranks as the 4th highest of 62 counties by effective property tax rate.
Cattaraugus County is one of the more affordable markets in New York. A median home value of $109,400 places entry-level pricing within reach for first-time buyers and investors alike. With FHA loans at 3.5% down or VA loans at 0%, the barrier to entry is often the lowest in the region. Lower valuations also mean lower absolute tax bills and insurance premiums. The trade-off may be distance from major employment centers or access to specific school districts. Buyers exploring this tier should compare commute cost and time against the lower purchase price. Rental demand in entry-priced markets is often steady, which supports the investor case. Household income in Cattaraugus County runs well below the New York average at $58,248. FHA, USDA, and down-payment assistance programs typically play a larger role in the financing mix here than in higher-income counties. The price-to-income ratio of 1.9x reflects a balanced profile for the region — median-income buyers have reasonable access to the market. Median gross rent runs $759 per month, giving renters a baseline to compare against ownership costs in the same market.
Property Tax Scenarios — Cattaraugus County
Entry-level markets still carry ongoing tax obligations. The scenarios below show what annual and monthly escrow looks like across five price points, from below median to above. Buyers evaluating a first purchase here should use these numbers to plan the full monthly carrying cost, not just principal and interest.
| Home Value | Annual Tax | Monthly Escrow | 10-Year Total |
|---|---|---|---|
| $55,000 | $1,481 | $123 | $14,812 |
| $80,000 | $2,154 | $180 | $21,544 |
| $110,000 | $2,962 | $247 | $29,623 |
| $165,000 | $4,443 | $370 | $44,435 |
| $220,000 | $5,925 | $494 | $59,246 |
Frequently asked questions
The questions below cover the most common concerns for buyers entering a high-property-tax jurisdiction. Each answer is grounded in Cattaraugus County's own rate, median home value, and Census-reported income figures.
What is the property tax rate in Cattaraugus County?
Cattaraugus County has an effective property tax rate of 2.693%, one of the highest in the country (national average: 1.07%). On a median home of $109,400, that's about $2,946 per year, or $246 monthly through escrow.
How much are property taxes on a home in Cattaraugus County?
At the county median of $109,400, annual property taxes run roughly $2,946, collected through mortgage escrow at about $246 per month.
How does Cattaraugus County compare to New York?
Cattaraugus County's 2.693% rate is substantially above New York's statewide average of 1.55%. The difference equals about $1,250 per year on a median home.
What is the median income in Cattaraugus County?
Median household income in Cattaraugus County is $58,248 (Census ACS 2023). Median gross rent runs $759 per month.
Are property taxes deductible in Cattaraugus County?
Yes, property taxes are deductible on federal returns when you itemize, subject to the SALT cap ($10,000 for most filers). Cattaraugus County homeowners paying $2,946 annually may benefit if their combined state and local tax burden exceeds the standard deduction.
How are property taxes calculated in Cattaraugus County?
The county assessor multiplies your home's assessed value by the local tax rate. On a $109,400 home at the county's effective rate of 2.693%, the annual bill is approximately $2,946.
Compare New York counties
Disclaimer: This calculator and the content on this page are for educational purposes only. They do not constitute financial, legal, or tax advice. Rates, loan limits, and eligibility criteria vary by lender, location, and borrower profile. Always consult a licensed financial professional before making borrowing decisions. CalcPier is independent and not affiliated with any lender listed on this page.
